Blogs

Feedback Opportunity: CalPERS Normal Retirement Age and Bona Fide Separation Regulatory Proposals

By Morgan Leskody posted 28 days ago

  

By: @Aaron Avery

The California Public Employees’ Retirement System (CalPERS) is undertaking a rulemaking related to both Normal Retirement Age (NRA) and Bona Fide Separation (BFS) from employment. CSDA is in the process of evaluating for possible comment and seeks member feedback.

Copies of the proposed regulations and CalPERS explanation, respectively, can be found here and here. This matter is in the pre-rulemaking phase where early feedback is most useful. The proposals are anticipated to be brought to the CalPERS Board of Administration in November to initiate formal rulemaking.  

If you wish to provide feedback for CSDA’s consideration, it would be most useful if received by October 15. Please share feedback, if any, directly with Aaron Avery at aarona@csda.net.  

NRA Change

CalPERS summarizes: Currently, the NRA is set at the highest age across all benefit formulas a member has earned service in regardless of how much time they’ve spent in each formula. This can lead to BFS violations which require reinstatement from retirement and impose costly penalties for retirees. We do not think this is what was intended when the regulation was adopted. Most recently, this has resulted in negative consequences for CalPERS retirees when employer audits identify violations, particularly involving peace officers who return as retired annuitants (RAs) to support seasonal events such as Race for the Cure, the state fair, concerts, and other occasions where additional law enforcement is needed to help ensure public safety.

The proposed amendment to 586.1 uses an 80/20 rule to clarify the NRA:

  • If a member earns service credit in one formula up to 80% or more that formula determines their NRA.
  • This ensures the NRA reflects the formula that represents the majority of the member’s career contributions.

Example: Currently, a Police Officer who spends 30 years in the Safety 3@50 formula but one year in a Miscellaneous 2@55 formula as a cadet would have their NRA set at 55. Not allowing the retiree to return to work as a retired annuitant (RA) before age 55, without waiting 60 days.

This causes confusion for employers and retirees as they would naturally assume the NRA would be set at 50 since that is the formula where most of the retirees service was earned. The proposed 80/20 rule would allow a retiree to return to work as an RA at age 50 without having to wait 60 days.

[NOTE: although the CalPERS explanation focuses on problems the current NRA rule is causing for post-retirement employment, the proposed change to the NRA rule to 80/20 appears to be generally applicable for purposes of determining when an employee may retire if a subsequent employer has a different NRA than the prior employer]

BFS Change

CalPERS summarizes: The amendment to 586.2 would align CalPERS law with the federal rules under IRC §401(a)(36)(A). Currently, the regulation does not recognize that a distribution at age of 59 ½ is permissible for a member who has not attained the NRA This revision would bring

CalPERS language into closer alignment with the federal requirement for a BFS from service only if a member has not attained the earlier of age 59 ½ or NRA.

(a) For purposes of working for a CalPERS covered employer after retirement pursuant to Article 8, of Chapter 12, Part 3, Division 5 of Title 2 of the Government Code, a retiree shall not be required to meet the requirements of a BFS in service when they either attain the normal retirement age based on all their retirement formulas (including the 80/20 rule), or attain age 59½.

If you wish to provide feedback for CSDA’s consideration, your answers to these questions would be especially helpful:

  1. Do you find that these proposals would be helpful or clarifying for your agency?
  2. Do you find that these proposals would be detrimental or cause confusion for your agency?
  3. Do you believe these proposals will increase or decrease liabilities for your agency based on subsequent or prior employment of your employees at other agencies?
  4. Do you believe that any amendments to the proposals should be considered?
  5. Any other feedback?

Stay tuned to CSDA Advocacy News and eNews for additional updates and information on how you can provide comments directly to CalPERS once the formal rulemaking begins.


#AdvocacyNews
#FeatureNews
#HR
#HumanResourcesandPersonnel
#HumanResources
#PensionsandRetirement
0 comments
45 views

Permalink